|
Client #1: Susan is a 40 year-old first-time offender
and mother of two with a 25-year history of drug abuse. Over a four-year
period, she defrauded the law firm where she worked as a secretary
of over $200,000.
Offense: Susan pled guilty to one count of Interstate
Transportation of Securities Obtained by Fraud in violation of 21
U.S.C. § 2314.
Jurisdiction: United States District Court for
the District of Columbia
Probation Office Recommendation: According to the Probation Office's
calculations of the Federal Sentencing Guidelines, Susan's total
adjusted offense level was 13 and her criminal history was I. Thus,
her recommended guideline imprisonment range was 12 to 18 months.
NCIA's Recommendation: NCIA highlighted several
issues in Susan's background for the Court to consider in passing
sentence, such as her 25-year history of substance abuse, as well
as the significant progress she had made in overcoming that addiction
after her arrest. In addition, we noted the adverse effect a substantial
period of incarceration would have on Susan's two young children,
one of whom was learning disabled. In light of the fact that substance
abuse is a prohibited grounds for departure under the Sentencing
Guidelines, NCIA recommended that Susan serve a 12-month sentence
in a local Bureau of Prisons-approved Community Corrections Center
(CCC). Susan's designation to a CCC would allow her to continue
attending her drug treatment program, as well as to maintain her
job at an area restaurant. Finally, we recommended that after completion
of her term of imprisonment, Susan perform 400 hours of community
service at a local church.
Outcome: Court adopted NCIA plan.
Client #2: William was a 30 year-old first-time
offender with a long-time gambling addiction. Over a one-year period,
he embezzled more than $100,000 from his employers in order to cover
loses he incurred while engaging in high-stakes gambling. Sensing
that his embezzlement would be discovered, William surrendered himself
to authorities and provided a full confession.
Offense: William pled guilty to one county of
Embezzlement Deemed Larceny, in violation of UCC § 18.2-111.
Jurisdiction: Arlington County Circuit Court,
Virginia
NCIA's Recommendation: While William faced a sentence
of between one and 20 years imprisonment, NCIA highlighted his pathological
gambling addiction and conducted extensive research into the topic
of compulsive gambling that demonstrated to the Court that he suffered
from a bona fide disease, rather than a simple failure of moral
judgment. Because William's offense conduct was so intimately tied
with his addiction, we requested that the Court consider a suspended
sentence with several conditions attached, including a six-month
stay at a residential gambling addiction treatment program. After
his release from that program, NCIA recommended that William serve
at least six months home confinement while attending outpatient
addiction counseling. Finally, in addition to providing restitution
to the company he defrauded, NCIA recommended that William complete
1,000 hours of community service with Habitat for Humanity.
Outcome: William was ordered to complete treatment
and make restitution as conditions of probation.
|